![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/04/02/15/11767540-6866479-image-a-1_1554213721922.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/03/29/20/11331370-0-image-a-86_1553890542386.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/03/29/20/11543344-0-image-a-87_1553891172241.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
![M. Wein Realty Inc., Shelter Island, NY/Listed & Sold: Ram Island, Gardiners Bay Waterfront Estate - Shelter Island, NY M. Wein Realty Inc., Shelter Island, NY/Listed & Sold: Ram Island, Gardiners Bay Waterfront Estate - Shelter Island, NY](http://photos.linkurealty.com/listing_pictures/4073/2015%20Barr.png)
M. Wein Realty Inc., Shelter Island, NY/Listed & Sold: Ram Island, Gardiners Bay Waterfront Estate - Shelter Island, NY
![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/03/29/20/11331382-0-image-a-52_1553889695146.jpg)